On 3 okt 2010, at 20:18, Guy Harris wrote:
> On Oct 3, 2010, at 5:08 AM, Sake Blok wrote:
>
>> I was able to make things work for "pcap_open_dead", but when trying to do the same for "bpf_image", I still run into problems at the linking stage where "bpf_image" can not be found. I checked the WinPcap header files and bpf_image is there.
>
> ...and, at least for WinPcap 4.1.1, bpf_image is in the .def file.
Which .def file are you referring too?
> Where is it failing?
It was failing in both "capture_filter_compile_cb" and "dumpcap.c", the only places where bpf_image is used. As long as HAVE_BPF_IMAGE is not defined, all is fine (except, the compile BPF button is not available and neither is dumpcap -d). But if I "add support for" bpf_image in the same way as I added support for pcap_open_dead, the linker complains that bpf_image can not be found.
> The buildbot seems to be doing OK.
That's because I did not want to break it yet another time, I have been pestering everyone enough this weekend ;-)
So when it did not work on my WinXP dev VM, I decided to ask here first!
>> Hmmm... do we need to define "HAVE_PCAP_COMPILE_NOPCAP" and check for it? Or can we safely assume it's there in all supported platforms?
>
> If we don't support any platforms that use libpcap before libpcap 0.5, we can safely assume it's there, although I think there might be some older versions of NetBSD where pcap_compile_nopcap() took an additional argument (a char * pointing to a buffer into which it put an error message if it failed - pcap_compile_nopcap() as implemented in tcpdump.org libpcap can't give you an error message for the failure, but pcap_open_dead()/pcap_compile() can).
>
> libpcap 0.4 had neither pcap_open_dead() nor pcap_compile_nopcap() - you *had* to have a live capture device or a savefile open in order to compile a filter into BPF code.
So, that sounds to me like we should just use these functions without adding complexity by using "HAVE_PCAP_COMPILE_NOPCAP" until someone knocks at our door telling us that (s)he has a problem with these functions on their platform.
Cheers,
Sake