Yves Geissb�hler wrote:
I have several protocols running on top of each other: TCP > MPA (RFC
5044) > [DDP (RFC 5042) | RDMAP (RFC 5040)].
Currently, I am calling my DDP/RDMAP dissector as a subdissector from
my MPA dissector. Because my DDP/RDMAP dissector could also be used
on top of SCTP (replacing TCP and MPA) calling it as a subdissector
from my MPA dissector does not seem to be the right solution anymore.
It would make more sense if my DDP/RDMAP dissector would get called
whenever there is MPA or SCTP traffic. So I would like to register my
DDP/RDMAP dissector for these to types of traffic.
I don't think you want to have your dissector be the *only* dissector
for the payload of SCTP traffic - that'd prevent the dissection of any
other protocol atop SCTP.
Therefore, there needs to be some way to arrange that only *some* SCTP
traffic be treated as DDP traffic.
There are a couple of ways of doing that:
1) have your dissector register with the SCTP dissector to be called
for particular SCTP port or PPI values (if there's a fixed value, use
that, otherwise make the value a preference);
2) have your dissector be a heuristic dissector.
In which manner do I have to return (in the proto_reg_handoff_mpa()?)
from my MPA dissector such that a call to heur_dissector_add("mpa",
dissect_ddp_rdmap, proto_ddp_rdmap) in my DDP/RDMAP dissector would
work?
If this is DDP over SCTP, with no MPA involved (MPA appears to exist
because TCP is byte-stream-oriented rather than packet-oriented; SCTP is
packet-oriented so that's not an issue), the MPA dissector wouldn't be
involved at all.
If the DDP dissector registers for a specific SCTP port or PPI, you
would call
dissector_add("sctp.port", {port number}, {handle for DDP dissector});
or
dissector_add("sctp.ppi", {PPI number}, {handle for DDP dissector});
in proto_reg_handoff_ddp().
If the DDP dissector is heuristic - which I infer from "such that a call
to heur_dissector_add("mpa", dissect_ddp_rdmap, proto_ddp_rdmap) in my
DDP/RDMAP dissector would work?" that it is - you would call
heur_dissector_add("sctp", dissect_ddp_rdmap, proto_ddp_rdmap);
in proto_reg_handoff_ddp().