[bugzilla-daemon@xxxxxxxxxxxxx]

Jim Young changed bug 12183

What	Removed	Added
Status	UNCONFIRMED	CONFIRMED
Ever confirmed		1

Comment # 9 on bug 12183 from Jim Young

> Has this part been fixed?

I'm unclear as to which part "this part" is. ;-)

Regarding the first part:

> 1. The fact that randpktdump is run by "default"

Running tshark with no parameters successfully starts capturing on the en0
interface.  No more randpktdump by default.

Regarding the second part:

> 2. Use-after-free error potentially caused by randpktdump running.

I just tested with very new buildbot image (Wireshark 2.1.0-3003-gd5031d5
(v2.1.0rc0-3003-gd5031d5 from unknown).

If I start Wireshark and start a capture with the Random packet generator:
randpkt I see no packets generated and when I stop the capture I get a dialog
box with the message:

> "Unexpected error from select: Interrupted system call"

I these messages in the Terminal window I launched Wireshark from:

> <snip>
> 15:28:07  Capture Msg  Capture Stop ...
> 15:28:07     Main Dbg  Callback: capture stopping
> 15:28:07  Capture Dbg  read 31 ok indicator: E len: 63 msg: E
> 15:28:07  Capture Msg  Error message from child: "Unexpected error from select: Interrupted system call", ""
> 15:28:14  Capture Dbg  read from pipe 31: EOF (capture closed?)
> 15:28:14  Capture Dbg  read 31 got an EOF
> 15:28:14  Capture Dbg  sync_pipe_wait_for_child: wait till child closed
> 15:28:14  Capture Dbg  sync_pipe_wait_for_child: capture child closed after 0.000s
> 15:28:14  Capture Dbg  sync_pipe_input_cb: cleaning extcap pipe
> 15:28:14  Capture Dbg  Extcap [randpkt] - Cleaning up fifo: /var/folders/9m/5pp94qw16cvdh2jbj9cbtpwm0000gn/T//wireshark_extcap_20160511152804_V7tvsI; PID: 17908
> 15:28:14  Capture Dbg  Extcap [randpkt] - Closing spawned PID: 17908
> 15:28:14  Capture Msg  Capture stopped.
> 15:28:14     Main Dbg  Callback: capture failed
> 15:28:14          Dbg  FIX: capture_info_ui_destroy
> 15:28:15  Capture Dbg  sync_interface_stats_open
> 15:28:15  Capture Dbg  sync_pipe_open_command
> 15:28:15  Capture Dbg  read 32 indicator: S empty value

Its important to note that Wireshark has NOT crashed, and I am able to
successfully capture on different interfaces.  But if I attempt a
multi-interface capture with randpkt as one of the two interface (for example
en0 (wifi in my case) and randpkt) I will see NOT capture any packets and will
get the same "Unexpected error from select: Interrupted system call" message
when stopping the capture.  I CAN successfully capture from multiple interfaces
if randpkt is NOT one of the selected interfaces.

I then listed the available interfaces with tshark -D and saw following (again
I have my wireshark profile running with a verbose console.log.level):

> jmac3:wireshark jyoung$ tshark -D
> Capture-Message: Capture Interface List ...
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG: sync_interface_list_open
> Capture-INFO: sync_pipe_run_command() starts
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[0]: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/dumpcap
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[1]: -D
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[2]: -Z
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[3]: none
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_open_command
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG: read 4 indicator: S empty value
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_wait_for_child: wait till child closed
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_wait_for_child: capture child closed after 0.000s
> Capture-INFO: sync_pipe_run_command() ends, taking 0.044s, result=0
> Capture-Message: Loading External Capture Interface List ...
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap pipe /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/androiddump 
> dyld: Library not loaded: @rpath/libssh.4.dylib
>   Referenced from: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/ciscodump
>   Reason: image not found
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap pipe /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/randpktdump 
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG:   Extcap [(null)] 
> (process:10977): Capture-DEBUG:   Interface [randpkt] "Random packet generator" 
> dyld: Library not loaded: @rpath/libssh.4.dylib
>   Referenced from: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/sshdump
>   Reason: image not found
> 1. en0 (Wi-Fi)
> 2. awdl0
> 3. bridge0 (Thunderbolt Bridge)
> 4. en1 (Thunderbolt 1)
> 5. en2 (Thunderbolt 2)
> 6. p2p0
> 7. lo0 (Loopback)
> 8. randpkt (Random packet generator)
> jmac3:wireshark jyoung$

Up until now I had sort of assumed that the "pointer being freed was not
allocated" had been fixed.  But a tshark -i randpkt seems to show otherwise:

> jmac3:wireshark jyoung$ tshark -i randpkt 
> Capture-Message: Capture Interface List ...
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_interface_list_open
> Capture-INFO: sync_pipe_run_command() starts
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[0]: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/dumpcap
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[1]: -D
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[2]: -Z
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[3]: none
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_open_command
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: read 4 indicator: S empty value
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_wait_for_child: wait till child closed
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_wait_for_child: capture child closed after 0.000s
> Capture-INFO: sync_pipe_run_command() ends, taking 0.041s, result=0
> Capture-Message: Loading External Capture Interface List ...
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap pipe /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/androiddump 
> dyld: Library not loaded: @rpath/libssh.4.dylib
>   Referenced from: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/ciscodump
>   Reason: image not found
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap pipe /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/randpktdump 
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   Extcap [(null)] 
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   Interface [randpkt] "Random packet generator" 
> dyld: Library not loaded: @rpath/libssh.4.dylib
>   Referenced from: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/sshdump
>   Reason: image not found
> Capture-Message: Capture Interface List ...
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_interface_list_open
> Capture-INFO: sync_pipe_run_command() starts
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[0]: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/dumpcap
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[1]: -D
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[2]: -Z
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   argv[3]: none
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_open_command
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: read 4 indicator: S empty value
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_wait_for_child: wait till child closed
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_wait_for_child: capture child closed after 0.000s
> Capture-INFO: sync_pipe_run_command() ends, taking 0.041s, result=0
> Capture-Message: Loading External Capture Interface List ...
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap pipe /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/androiddump 
> dyld: Library not loaded: @rpath/libssh.4.dylib
>   Referenced from: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/ciscodump
>   Reason: image not found
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap pipe /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/randpktdump 
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   Extcap [(null)] 
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG:   Interface [randpkt] "Random packet generator" 
> dyld: Library not loaded: @rpath/libssh.4.dylib
>   Referenced from: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/sshdump
>   Reason: image not found
> Capturing on 'Random packet generator'
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_start
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: CAPTURE OPTIONS     :
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Interface name[00]  : randpkt
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Interface description[00] : Random packet generator
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Console display name[00]: Random packet generator
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Capture filter[00]  : (unspecified)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Snap length[00] (0) : 262144
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Link Type[00]       : -1
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Promiscuous Mode[00]: TRUE
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap[00]          : /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/randpktdump
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap FIFO[00]     : (unspecified)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap PID[00]      : -1
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Buffer size[00]     : 2 (MB)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Monitor Mode[00]    : FALSE
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Interface name[df]  : (unspecified)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Interface Descr[df] : (unspecified)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Capture filter[df]  : (unspecified)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Snap length[df] (0) : 262144
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Link Type[df]       : -1
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Promiscuous Mode[df]: TRUE
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap[df]          : (unspecified)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap FIFO[df]     : (unspecified)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Buffer size[df]     : 2 (MB)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Monitor Mode[df]    : FALSE
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: SavingToFile        : 0
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: SaveFile            : 
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: GroupReadAccess     : 0
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Fileformat          : PCAPNG
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: RealTimeMode        : 1
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: ShowInfo            : 1
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: QuitAfterCap        : 0
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: MultiFilesOn        : 0
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: FileDuration    (0) : 60
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: RingNumFiles    (0) : 0
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: AutostopFiles   (0) : 1
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: AutostopPackets (0) : 0
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: AutostopFilesize(0) : 1000 (KB)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: AutostopDuration(0) : 60
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap - Creating fifo: /var/folders/9m/5pp94qw16cvdh2jbj9cbtpwm0000gn/T//wireshark_extcap_20160511151243_3J1ee4
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap path /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[0]: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/randpktdump
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[1]: --capture
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[2]: --extcap-interface
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[3]: randpkt
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[4]: --fifo
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[5]: /var/folders/9m/5pp94qw16cvdh2jbj9cbtpwm0000gn/T//wireshark_extcap_20160511151243_3J1ee4
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[6]: --type 
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[0]: /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/dumpcap
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[1]: -n
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[2]: -i
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[3]: /var/folders/9m/5pp94qw16cvdh2jbj9cbtpwm0000gn/T//wireshark_extcap_20160511151243_3J1ee4
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[4]: -Z
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: argv[5]: none
> /Applications/Wireshark.app/Contents/MacOS/extcap/randpktdump --capture --extcap-interface randpkt --fifo /var/folders/9m/5pp94qw16cvdh2jbj9cbtpwm0000gn/T//wireshark_extcap_20160511151243_3J1ee4 --type  
> Generating packets: dns
> ^C
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: read 6 ok indicator: E len: 63 msg: E
> tshark: Unexpected error from select: Interrupted system call
> 
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: read from pipe 6: EOF (capture closed?)
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: read 6 got an EOF
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_wait_for_child: wait till child closed
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_wait_for_child: capture child closed after 0.000s
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: sync_pipe_input_cb: cleaning extcap pipe
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap [randpkt] - Cleaning up fifo: /var/folders/9m/5pp94qw16cvdh2jbj9cbtpwm0000gn/T//wireshark_extcap_20160511151243_3J1ee4; PID: 11591
> (process:11570): Capture-DEBUG: Extcap [randpkt] - Closing spawned PID: 11591
> 0 packets captured
> ** (process:11570): DEBUG: input pipe closed
> tshark(11570,0x7fff7b360300) malloc: *** error for object 0xa706d75640034: pointer being freed was not allocated
> *** set a breakpoint in malloc_error_break to debug
> Abort trap: 6
> jmac3:wireshark jyoung$

It appears that the original issue described in bug title has not in fact been
resolved. :-(

But now that randpkt is no longer the default interface it is less likely that
Joe Random User is likely to stumble upon the "pointer being freed was not
allocated".

---

      You are receiving this mail because:

• You are watching all bug changes.