Audric Schiltknecht
changed
bug 8522
| What |
Removed |
Added |
| Status |
INCOMPLETE
|
RESOLVED
|
| Resolution |
---
|
NOTABUG
|
Comment # 12
on bug 8522
from Audric Schiltknecht
Evan, Guy,
Thanks for your answers and sorry for the (long) delay.
(In reply to comment #10)
> So in what circumstances is this encapsulation used?
>
> Is it on an Ethernet on which other protocols are running, where you're
> actually sending the frames from one machine to one or more hosts to process
> ("more hosts", in the case of the test capture, as it's being sent to the
> broadcast address), or is this a hack similar to Cisco's
> DOCSIS-over-Ethernet hack, where the lowest-level Ethernet framing is being
> used, but the actual contents of the frame is a DOCSIS frame and there's no
> Ethernet header on the frame? (It's "DOCSIS-over-Ethernet" to support
> sniffing DOCSIS traffic without requiring special hardware on your sniffer,
> not "DOCSIS-over-Ethernet" to support transporting DOCSIS packets over an
> Ethernet for communications purposes.)
Its the later: a low-level ethernet framing is used but the content of the
frame is the SATLAB mode adaptation payload, in order to allow sniffing traffic
with a common equipment, kind like the DOCSIS-over-Ethernet you described.
Again, this is because the SATLAB specification did not define the low-level
layer to transport the DVB-S2 payload. It'd be great if they do so...
>
> If the former, you appear to be using fields with a length field rather than
> a type field; if the DVB-S2 frame immediately follows the 14-byte Ethernet
> header, that's not a valid Ethernet frame, as an 802.2 header should follow
> an Ethernet header with a length field.
I understand very well that this format is not a valid ethernet frame, as a
matter of fact, we dropped this equipment to work with one using the already
implemented dissector, ie using UDP, easier to use. Thus, I think it is all
right to drop the patch and mark this request as resolved.
Thanks,
Audric
You are receiving this mail because:
- You are watching all bug changes.